Crown Owl Printing← Back to siteHow much do business cards actually cost in NYC? (2026)
Short answer: anywhere from $25 to $150 for 500 cards, depending on where you buy and what stock you pick. Here's the honest breakdown so you don't overpay — or underbuy.
The 2026 price landscape (500 cards)
- Big-box ship-and-copy stores: typically $60–90 for standard 14–16pt. Convenient, priciest per card.
- Giant online printers: $25–60 — until the upsells, shipping and "premium stock" add-ons stack up at checkout.
- Local NYC print shops: $40–90 depending on the shop and stock.
- Crown Owl (Staten Island): from $39 for 500 on sturdy 16pt, matte or gloss — priced live on our calculator with no checkout surprises.
What changes the price
- Stock thickness: 14pt is fine; 16pt feels solid (worth it); 18pt laminated feels like a credit card and costs roughly double.
- One side vs. two (4/0 vs 4/4): printing the back usually adds 10–25%. Use the back — it's the cheapest ad space you'll ever buy.
- Finish: gloss UV pops, matte feels premium, uncoated is writable (appointment cards).
- Quantity: per-card cost drops fast — 1,000 cards usually costs only ~25% more than 500.
The mistake that costs more than any markup
Bad artwork. Blurry logos, missing bleed, RGB colors that print muddy — reprints cost more than any price difference between shops. Every Crown Owl order includes a free file check before printing, and defects are reprinted free. That's the real math.
More Staten Island printing guides: Flyer costs · Yard sign costs · EDDM postcards explained · Areas we serve
See your exact card price in 10 seconds →
Crown Owl Printing LLC · Staten Island, NY · (929) 661-7208 · info@coprinting.org